UFR 1-07 Evaluation
Unsteady Near-Field Plumes
Underlying Flow Regime 1-07
Comparison of DesJardin et al. [1] CFD Calculations with Experiments
Figure 11 shows a snapshot of the flow field predicted by the CFD model of DesJardin et al. [1]. With the coarse grid, the plume puffing frequency was found to be approximately 1.8 Hz, much higher than the frequency measured in the experiments of 1.37 Hz. The predictions improved as the grid was refined, with the fine grid producing a frequency of 1.5 Hz. A similar frequency was obtained with or without an SGS model. DesJardin et al. [1] also presented results from a simulation with no SGS model and a very coarse mesh (220k nodes in total and only 30 cells across the source diameter). This produced a puffing frequency of 1.7 Hz, which they considered to be an adequate estimate for engineering purposes, although the axial velocity in this case was overpredicted by nearly a factor of two.
Contributed by: Simon Gant — UK Health & Safety Laboratory
© copyright ERCOFTAC 2010