DNS 1-3 Quantification of Resolution: Difference between revisions

From KBwiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 28: Line 28:


===Velocity profiles and RMS quantities===
===Velocity profiles and RMS quantities===
The 10000 Reynolds number diffuser has been simulated and compared with the results with previous DNS data from [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et al.''  (2010)]] and experimental data from [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Cherry ''et al.''  (2008)]].  
The 10000 Reynolds number diffuser has been simulated and compared with the results with previous DNS data from [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et al.''  (2010)]] and experimental data from [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Cherry ''et al.''  (2008)]]. [[lib:DNS_1-3_quantification_#figure3|Fig. 3]] and [[lib:DNS_1-3_quantification_#figure4|Fig. 4]] show the averaged velocities and the RMS quantities along the characteristic lines of the diffuser for the experimental data and both DNS simulations.


 
<div id="figure3"></div>
 
<div id="figure2"></div>
{|align="center" width=750
{|align="center" width=750
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_fig2.png|740px]]
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_U_comparison.png|740px]]
|-
|-
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_fig3.png|740px]]
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_V_comparison.png|740px]]
|-
|-
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_fig3.png|740px]]
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_W_comparison.png|740px]]
|-
|-
|'''Figure 2:''' Stanford double diffuser, Re=10000, preliminary validation. Average streamwise velocity, [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2010)]] vs preliminary data obtained with Alya.
|'''Figure 3:''' Stanford double diffuser, Re=10000, validation. Average velocities, [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#5|Cherry ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2008)]] and [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2010)]] vs data obtained with Alya.
|}
|}


<div id="figure3"></div>
<div id="figure4"></div>
{|align="center" width=750
{|align="center" width=750
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_fig3.png|740px]]
|[[Image:DNS_1_3_urms_comparison.png|740px]]
|-
|-
|'''Figure 3:''' Stanford double diffuser, Re=10000, preliminary validation. Average streamwise velocity fluctuations, [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2010)]] vs preliminary data obtained with Alya.
|'''Figure 4:''' Stanford double diffuser, Re=10000, validation. Average streamwise velocity fluctuations, [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#5|Cherry ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2008)]] and [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2010)]] vs data obtained with Alya.
|}
|}


In [[lib:DNS_1-3_quantification_#figure2|Fig. 2]] and [[lib:DNS_1-3_quantification_#figure3|Fig. 3]] results are presented with reference data from [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2010)]]. Fair agreement is observed between both calculations, proving that the approach to be used in the present proposal is an optimal strategy. Turbulent inlet was generated in a precursor domain using a long enough duct with a roughness element to trigger the laminar to turbulent transition.
[[lib:DNS_1-3_quantification_#figure3|Fig. 3]] and [[lib:DNS_1-3_quantification_#figure4|Fig. 4]] show a fair agreement between both numerical simulations, proving that the approach used is an optimal strategy. Moreover, the points where the DNS performed with Alya deviates from the results of [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#1|Ohlsson ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2010)]], this is in favour to move closer to the experimental data of [[lib:DNS_1-3_description#5|Cherry ''et&nbsp;al.''  (2008)]]. Thus, a good agreement is also obtained with the experiment. The inclusion of a roughness element on the long inlet duct is shown to have a negligible effect on the quality of the results.
 


===Other turbulent statistics===
===Other turbulent statistics===

Revision as of 11:09, 22 November 2021


Front Page

Description

Computational Details

Quantification of Resolution

Statistical Data

Instantaneous Data

Storage Format

Quantification of resolution

Mesh resolution

The mesh resolution is quantified by obtaining a relation between the mesh characteristic length () and the characteristics lengths, i.e., the Taylor microscale () and Kolmogorov length scale (). The former relation is shown in Fig. 1 while the latter is reported in Fig. 2. As it can be seen, both relations indicate that the resolution achieved by the present grid is at DNS level. In particular, it is commonly accepted that DNS is achieved when , as shown in Fig. 2.

DNS 1 3 taylor.png
Figure 1: Stanford double diffuser, Alya DNS-250M DoF, relation between the mesh size and the Taylor microscale.
DNS 1 3 delta vs eta.png
Figure 2: Stanford double diffuser, Alya DNS-250M DoF, relation between the mesh size and the Kolmogorov length scale.

Solution verification

This section aims to provide an insight on the dataset freely available in this wiki this wiki. Simulation results are compared with the DNS of Ohlsson et al. (2010) and the experimental data of Cherry et al. (2008). The grid resolution has been proven to be fine enough to be at DNS level. An animation of the fluctuations of this flow can be seen in this link.

Velocity profiles and RMS quantities

The 10000 Reynolds number diffuser has been simulated and compared with the results with previous DNS data from Ohlsson et al. (2010) and experimental data from Cherry et al. (2008). Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 show the averaged velocities and the RMS quantities along the characteristic lines of the diffuser for the experimental data and both DNS simulations.

DNS 1 3 U comparison.png
DNS 1 3 V comparison.png
DNS 1 3 W comparison.png
Figure 3: Stanford double diffuser, Re=10000, validation. Average velocities, Cherry et al. (2008) and Ohlsson et al. (2010) vs data obtained with Alya.
DNS 1 3 urms comparison.png
Figure 4: Stanford double diffuser, Re=10000, validation. Average streamwise velocity fluctuations, Cherry et al. (2008) and Ohlsson et al. (2010) vs data obtained with Alya.

Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 show a fair agreement between both numerical simulations, proving that the approach used is an optimal strategy. Moreover, the points where the DNS performed with Alya deviates from the results of Ohlsson et al. (2010), this is in favour to move closer to the experimental data of Cherry et al. (2008). Thus, a good agreement is also obtained with the experiment. The inclusion of a roughness element on the long inlet duct is shown to have a negligible effect on the quality of the results.


Other turbulent statistics

Reynolds stresses budget equation terms




Contributed by: Oriol Lehmkuhl, Arnau Miro — Barcelona Supercomputing Center (BSC)

Front Page

Description

Computational Details

Quantification of Resolution

Statistical Data

Instantaneous Data

Storage Format


© copyright ERCOFTAC 2024